5 Extra Thoughtful First Valentine Gifts For Girlfriends in 2023

Welcome to our list of thoughtful first Valentine gifts for girlfriends!

It can be daunting to pick out the perfect first Valentine’s Day gift for your new girlfriend. After all, you want to choose something that will show her how much you care without coming on too strong. Ideally, you want to give her a Valentine gift that celebrates your relationship together and the things you love about her. 

Instead of the usual coffee mug, generic picture frame, or unadorned scrapbook, we’ve rounded up a carefully curated selection of Valentine gifts that will make your girlfriend feel special. The truth is that no matter what you choose, the most important thing is that your gift comes from the heart.

So without further ado, take a look and find the perfect first Valentine gift for her in 2023!

Thoughtful First Valentine Gifts For Girlfriends in 2023

  1. I Love You in 100 Languages Necklace
  2. I Love You in 100 Languages Necklace

    The first Valentine's Day is a special occasion for any couple. It's a time to celebrate your love for each other and to make memories that will last a lifetime. If you're looking for the perfect first Valentine's Day gift for your girlfriend, look no further than the Preserved Rose Jewel Case + Necklace. This beautiful gift features a preserved rose in a glass jewel case, with the words "I Love You" hidden inside the bottom of the box. The necklace is also inscribed with the words "I Love You" in 100 languages, making it a truly unique and thoughtful gift. Your girlfriend is sure to appreciate the thoughtfulness and uniqueness of this first Valentine's Day gift, and she'll cherish it for years to come.

    Buy Now
  3. Shawty You Fine Teddy Bear
  4. Shawty You Fine Teddy Bear

    This year, make your first Valentine's Day together extra special with a Hollabear. Hollabears are 10 inches tall, the perfect size and shape to hug or display. They're made of very soft high quality material (think fleece blanket), not just a toy from the corner store. And the best part is that they have everlasting embroidered words on a velvety plush heart. So you can make your intentions clear and get out of the friendzone. Order your Hollabear today and make this Valentine's Day one to remember.

    Buy Now
  5. Romantic Game For Couples
  6. Romantic Game For Couples

    Whether you want a first Valentine's Day gift for your girlfriend or a way to spice up your relationship, Flirt & Dare cards are a great option! With three levels of closeness to choose from - Talk, Flirt or Dare - you can pick the level of intimacy you're comfortable with. And with no complicated rules, simply pick a card and answer the question or complete the dare with your partner. This is a great way to refuel the connection in your marriage or relationship. Plus, the Talk cards include questions to start fun couple conversations at parties - perfect for breaking the ice! The Flirt & Dare cards make a lovely gift for him or her, and they're sure to be a hit at your next date night. So why not give them a try?

    Buy Now
  7. You Are My Sunshine Music Box
  8. You Are My Sunshine Music Box

    A music box is a wonderful first Valentine gift for your girlfriend. It's a beautiful and romantic way to show your love, and it's a gift that she can cherish forever. There are many different styles of music boxes available, so you can find one that suits her taste perfectly. From delicate and ornate designs to fun and whimsical ones, there's sure to be a music box that she'll adore. And because music boxes don't require batteries, she'll never have to worry about them running out of power. She can simply crank the handle to enjoy the lovely melody. So if you're looking for a first Valentine gift that's both unique and romantic, a music box is the perfect choice.

    Buy Now
  9. Sterling Silver Heart Rose Necklace
  10. Sterling Silver Heart Rose Necklace

    Check out this unique rose heart design. Whether it's a necklace, earrings, or a charm bracelet, this heartfelt gesture is sure to fill her with love and happiness for your first Valentine as a couple. She'll be reminded of your love every time she wears it, and all of the laughter you've shared together. With such a sweet and romantic gift, she's sure to fall head over heels for you all over again. So go ahead and make this Valentine's Day one to remember with a rose heart design from Sterling Silver.

    Buy Now


People Also Ask These Questions About First Valentine Gifts For Girlfriends

Q: What are some popular first Valentine gifts for girlfriends?

  • First Valentine’s Day gifts for girlfriends can vary widely depending on the couple’s relationship status and the girlfriend’s personality and interests. If the relationship is still fairly new, a simple but thoughtful gift such as flowers, chocolates, or jewelry is usually well-received. For couples who have been together longer, some women prefer more unique or personal gifts such as tickets to a show or a day of spa treatments. And of course, many women simply appreciate a heartfelt card or handwritten love note. 

Q: What are some appropriate gifts to give a girlfriend for your first Valentine’s Day together?

  • While flowers and chocolates are always appreciated, there are many other gifts that can be given to a girlfriend on Valentine’s Day. For example, a heartfelt letter expressing one’s love and admiration can be a lasting and cherished gift. A special piece of jewelry or an item of clothing that has significant meaning can also be a thoughtful present. Alternatively, some couples prefer to give experiences rather than physical gifts. Tickets to a show or a romantic dinner at a favorite restaurant can create lasting memories. Whatever the gift, it is important to select something that is meaningful and reflects the relationship between the two partners. 

Q: What are some affordable first Valentine gifts for girlfriends?

  • It can be tough to come up with the perfect Valentine’s Day gift, especially if you’re on a budget. However, there are plenty of ways to show your girlfriend how much you care without breaking the bank. One affordable option is to DIY a small project like a scrapbook or photo album. This is a thoughtful way to show her your favorite memories together. Another idea is to cook dinner for her or pick up her favorite treat. If you’re feeling extra creative, you could write her a heartfelt letter expressing your love and appreciation.